Never­theless, poisoned patients are often unnecessar­ily subjected to these potentially harmful meas­ures, and the literature is full of anecdotal accounts of miraculous recovery attributed to such treatment (Winchester et al. 1977). Prop­erly controlled clinical trials are difficult to carry out, and very few have been published. With the possible exception of forced alkaline di­uresis for poisoning with salicylate and long act­ing barbiturates such as phenobarbitone, none of these methods for enhancement of drug re­moval has ever been shown to reduce morbidity or mortality in poisoned patients (Todd 1984).

Indeed, some studies suggest the opposite result. This is not to say that such measures are never necessary, or indeed sometimes life saving, but a more critical appraisal of their role is required.

In some cases, the drug presumed to have been taken has never been chemically identi­fied, while, in others, haemodialysis has been carried out in patients with less than therapeutic plasma concentrations of the drug in question. Other studies have shown removal of only a very small and insignificant fraction of the ingested dose, sometimes amounting to the equivalent of less than 1 tablet or capsule (see, for example, Comstock et al. 1983; Heath et al. 1983). A mis­leading impression of efficacy may be gained by the use of nonspecific analytical methods for drug assay (Prescott 1974).

Other Binding Agents

Other agents have been used in attempts to bind unabsorbed drug in the gastrointestinal tract. Paraquat, a lethal weedkiller for which there is no known antidote, binds very strongly to Fuller’s earth and bentonite, and these ad­sorbents are used routinely in the treatment of paraquat poisoning.

Although bentonite may re­duce the normally slow absorption of paraquat in pure aqueous solution in rats (Smith et al. 1974), ail the evidence points to extremely rapid absorption of paraquat from commercial weed­killers in man. Our experience of paraquat poi poi­soning has been disastrous, with no apparent benefit from the early use of bentonite.

Cholestyramine binds acidic drugs and can reduce the absorption of paracetamol (aceta­minophen) taken at the same time. Like acti­vated charcoal, however, it is virtually useless when the delay between ingestion and admin­istration exceeds 1 hour (Dordoni et al. 1973).